California legislators claim letting citizens know what's in legislation is too risky

| No TrackBacks
When the California Teachers Association, the powerful union that is the Golden State's most influential special interest, says "jump", the Democrats who control Sacramento consistently ask "How high?" So it was last year, when the CTA got its legislative allies to muscle through a bill preventing teacher layoffs for the coming year and requiring union approval of furloughs aimed at addressing the state's crippling budget crisis. How did the legislature pass such an obvious giveaway without intense media scrutiny? Simple. They didn't make it public until an hour before the vote.
As a new report from the Associated Press makes clear, that's standard fare in California, where efforts to impose legislative transparency (which are mandatory for the state's local governments) have consistently been thwarted by (you guessed it) the legislators themselves. By completely removing and replacing the content of proposed bills or by simply waiving floor rules, the legislators can dodge the requirement that bills must be read for at least three days prior to a vote.

This sort of malfeasance isn't exactly novel in political circles (remember the wretched 111th Congress?), but traditionally its practitioners have either denied any wrongdoing or kept quiet. Not so in California. According to Democratic Assemblyman Charles Calderon, keeping the public in the dark is a necessary component of good government. From the AP report:

He said Republicans are not thinking of the public in trying to require a 24-hour waiting period. Instead, Calderon said they would only use that time to gin up opposition and punish lawmakers who approve good but politically risky policies.

"A 24-hour reading period often gets used for mischief," said Calderon, the longest-serving lawmaker in the Capitol. "Democrats are the majority party, and they have the responsibility to vote for things sometimes that are not popular with the public.

So, just to review, Democrats in the California Legislature are operating in service of  political courage -- courage so thoroughgoing that it prevents them from debating the Republicans who they outnumber approximately 2 to 1 or disclosing the content of their work to voters. If that's courage, perhaps California could use a little more cowardice. 



No TrackBacks

TrackBack URL: http://www.publicsectorinc.com/cgi-bin/mt/mt-tb.cgi/795

Related Entries:

Center for State and Local Leadership

PublicSectorInc.org is a project of the Manhattan Institute's Center for State & Local Leadership.
Copyright © 2013 Manhattan Institute for Policy Research, Inc. All rights reserved.
52 Vanderbilt Avenue, New York, N.Y. 10017
phone (212) 599-7000 / fax (212) 599-3494